Trapps
ALLIANCE MEMBER
Simply awesome!




Things I liked about the GTI:
Things that I won’t miss:
- Exterior design
- Green color
- Infotainment
- Engine lacked personality
- Gearing wasn’t enjoyable
- Not fun to drive in Michigan
I like my Focus ST.However, 9 yrs in I'm used to it now, the good and the bad, and I can't think of another daily driver I'd rather have that can comfortably haul two kids in carseats for an appropriate amount of money. Except maybe a Golf R![]()
So now you're GTI-less?!
I can't remember, do you still have the Alltrack?
I would agree with most of that. Was yours a manual or DSG? Mine is manual and I've long complained about the gearing to anyone who will listen
However, 9 yrs in I'm used to it now, the good and the bad, and I can't think of another daily driver I'd rather have that can comfortably haul two kids in carseats for an appropriate amount of money. Except maybe a Golf R![]()


As for not having a GTI...I don't really want to buy another car until I have more space, but I really enjoy the idea of a MKIV R32, GTI 337, or GTI 20th. Would need to be very clean, and that would mean storing indoors, so I'll need to do something about garage space.
I fully support this!
In all honesty, I picked up an mk4 golf tdi w/5spd, its a blast, put a cup kit on it and its fun and peppy around town. Just another option, that can be made to look just like an r32 or other anniversary edition car and not pay the tax
I like my Focus ST.
Yeah, no GTI, and it was manual. We do have the Alltrack still!
It's funny - the driving the Alltrack is a much better experience than the GTI was for a couple of reasons.
1) The clutch feel is better. Doesn't feel like it has the delay valve, and there might be different clutch/pressure plate / hydraulics. Not sure, but it's way better
2) Shorter final drive on the Alltrack really improves drivability in my opinion. It appears that the GTI has a closer ratio spread 1-4, but the 3.94 final drive in the Alltrack (gears 1-4) vs. the 3.24 final drive in the GTI (gears 1-4) is probably what I'm noticing. See below:
Don't get me started!
I don't know how they managed to make the clutch pedal feel so bad on the GTI. I removed the delay valve in mine, as well as the 'helper spring' attached to the pedal itself. And turned off the 'Soundakator' speaker to hear the engine revs better. And added a small clutch stop to reduce pedal travel a bit. Those things all helped a lot. Still though... it's not the greatest. When I first got the car I had issues killing the engine, especially on inclines, despite having driven my manual Mk4 Jetta for 10 yrs. After taking that stupid delay valve out I no longer felt like I was going crazy.
I've often wondered if an aftermarket clutch with a heavier or springier pressure plate would help it.
The gearing, though...
I think you have your charts labeled backwards, but that's interesting the Alltrack has almost the same 1st and 2nd as the GTI but shorter final drive. The GTI may be a *close-er* ratio transmission than the Alltrack, but the 3,24 final drive certainly isn't helping and I CAN'T STAND the spread between 1st-2nd, which is ~45%. I've learned to live with it and match my revs on upshifts, waiting for them to fall, ever so slowly, but it would feel so much sportier with a closer 1-2 shift. They basically gave the GTI two highway gears and a super spread out 1-2. Takes all the fun out of sub-30mph neighborhood or traffic driving.
I've heard some people say it's because FWD and torque, and yeah the Golf R has AWD but they gave the manual in that better spreads (at least on paper!).
And not only that, but the DSG version of the Mk7 GTI is quite a bit different. I've also never driven the DSG, but I imagine it feels much faster and snappier through the first three gears.
Mk7 GTI ~Speed MPH at redline (6300rpm)
1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th
6MT 39.46 73.10 101.63 137.39 168.62 200.52
DSG 36.43 59.44 93.32 136.40 183.43 231.28
I haven't driven that many performance-oriented cars so most of this is coming from my GTI experience, but I do find the tech specs interesting and I think your complaints are totally valid.
Anyways... I like the idea on the Mk4 special editions. In terms of looks and sounds a blue Mk4 R32 has always been a grail for me.
Fixed the charts!
So the Alltrack does have a very similar 1-2 spread, but it’s hardly noticeable with the shorter gearing. I think that if I ever have it full throttle in first gear (I don’t…) I might complain that the 1-2 feels too far apart. But, shift on a relaxed take-off and 2nd feels perfect on the Alltrack.
Now, the 2.0L GTI engine has a lot more to offer than the 1.8L on the Alltrack. That said, the 1.8L is competent with exactly zero surplus power haha
My brother has a K04 and a South Bend with single mass flywheel in his MKV and I wouldn’t enjoy driving that much with the dump truck rattles and the heavy clutch. The power is nice thoughWhen I first got my MK7 GTI removing the delay valve and helper spring were the very first things I did. It was terrible lol. I've been on a Southbend Stage 3 clutch now though for 60k miles so I don't really remember how it felt stock but I am happy with how it is now. It is on the heavier side but not terrible, only really noticable when I switch between driving my tacoma with a super light clutch and then back to the GTI.
Sounds like you need to put an IS20 or IS38 on the alltrack....
IS20/38 might be nice if I can find an OEM feel clutch for it. I imagine that a Golf R unit would work for either if the torque were kept in check. Somewhat appealing but for now I don’t drive the car much so it’s fineWhen I first got my MK7 GTI removing the delay valve and helper spring were the very first things I did. It was terrible lol. I've been on a Southbend Stage 3 clutch now though for 60k miles so I don't really remember how it felt stock but I am happy with how it is now. It is on the heavier side but not terrible, only really noticable when I switch between driving my tacoma with a super light clutch and then back to the GTI.
Sounds like you need to put an IS20 or IS38 on the alltrack....
IS20/38 might be nice if I can find an OEM feel clutch for it. I imagine that a Golf R unit would work for either if the torque were kept in check. Somewhat appealing but for now I don’t drive the car much so it’s fine
There is appeal to this for sure.SACHS makes a performance clutch for the Mk7 GTI, not sure if it would work for the Alltrack. But it is supposedly very OEM-like (maybe a tad heavier pedal) and uses the OEM dual-mass flywheel.
Looking for feedback here. First estimate back from a GC with garage experience can in at $90k for 32x60 stuck built including concrete and the notes below:
Sound like a lowball? Comes out to $48/sqf including concrete. Seems low to me
I was around 70 dollars a square foot and I did most of it myself. 30x50 metal building. That's in East TN. My concrete alone was 20k.
I don't have any firm or recent data points, but my attached 24x32 was ~$32k back in 2019-2020 time frame, so I'd agree, its seems low. BUT, if its a savvy builder that is watching material prices, an IF they are low b/c its the off season, AND they would buy/order all the materials now that is the "off season"...Maybe its reasonable
The concrete is the hard one for me to have a good point of reference




I just found your thread the other day and got caught up on the entire thing. I love the new house with the huge wrap-around porch. Beautiful design.Looking for feedback here. First estimate back from a GC with garage experience can in at $90k for 32x60 stuck built including concrete and the notes below:
- 32x60
- 14' walls
- 12/12 roof pitch to match house
- Attic trusses (unfinished attic)
- Hardie Plank siding to match house
- 4 garage doors
- 5 windows similar to house on gable ends
- Eave end facing house w/ 5 windows + two man doors
- No insulation / drywall inside
- No plumbing
- Wraparound porch similar to house (concrete apron instead of wood)
Sound like a lowball? Comes out to $48/sqf including concrete. Seems low to me
Thanks for the compliment on the house. Have enjoyed following along with your thread. Your thread has opened my eyes to the minor setbacks I could expect while pursuing a build. To that end, I’m sort of considering a project manager between me and the GC, as I would like to see my vision come to life, but do not enjoy the attention to detail / perfectionism required to get that result.I just found your thread the other day and got caught up on the entire thing. I love the new house with the huge wrap-around porch. Beautiful design.
Maybe it is the area but I agree that seems extremely low. I couldn't even get a quote for double that for a stick build garage when I considered going that route in this area. Knowing the cost of even the cheapest garage doors would make me question that estimate.
One suggestion, even if you are not insulating now, you might want to get insulated garage doors now since you are up north. They do help make a difference unless you never plan to insulate the building at all versus just doing it yourself later. Also, walls 2x6 or 2x4?



















Did not expect to enjoy it this much. When it finally came to market I was working at Stellantis and had a $700/mo (including insurance) $0 down, unlimited mile lease on a Pacifica pinnacle hybrid. At that point I liked the Pacifica enough to just stick with it. When I left Stellantis and we test drove a Buzz I got hookedNice color! The two-tone is cool. I’m not in the market for (any) new car at the moment but I am oddly attracted to the Buzz. More than I thought I would would.





