And now, for Science, let's look at the old oil filter:
One of my old $3 drain pans, with some oil in it from some other dumb projects. Dome of the oil filter is a little collapsed from me tapping a hole into it the night of the LHO (long/hot/overnight) oil drain. My previous Subaru oil changes have been tidy affairs, even with the oil filter pointing down, but I thought I'd try giving air a chance to get in this way. Conclusion: no real difference.
On the right, my overpriced Longacre oil filter cutter.
It's one cutting wheel and two roller bearings. Except I can't get the cutting wheel to touch the canister! Hey, this filter is small!
Went and got some tools and moved the roller bearings to the closer holes, which I had never noticed before this day. Now they will live in the closer holes until the day I have to open a very large filter.
A couple of go-rounds with a half turn tightening of the threaded rod/cutting wheel with each revolution, and it's off!
Silicon anti-drainback valve, bypass spring (I think) filter, can.
Here are the lines showing ferrous metals that the FilterMag that I put on the outside of the oil filter trapped.
Now I'll smear it with a finger to make it clear what's going on there.
Of course, most particles are big enough to be trapped by the filter media. Some say that the microscopic particles that can sneak through the filter media are so small the magnet doesn't catch them. (I have no idea what that theory is based on.) Some harp on the fact that the particles you see would have been trapped by the filter, and therefore, this magnet device is a waste of time. Because the particles that are too small to see won't be trapped by it. (Uh, again, they lose me there.)
Some also say that particles small enough to make it through the filter media can't cause any wear because the crankshaft and connecting rod journals are riding on a hydrodynamic wedge of oil. Yes. They sure do that. But that's not the only kind of relative motion between metal parts in an engine, and that kind of oil wedge isn't always present, silly. Pistons at the top and bottom of their strokes are not always riding the film like you'd think, either.
Also, FilterMag claims that they have industrial customers who have put their magnets on the oil filter for their machinery and gotten much longer lifespans out of such engines/machines since moving to the magnets. If FilterMag isn't making that up out of whole cloth, then I'm going to pay attention to that. Their counter-theory to the above, that, when it comes to wear, fewer suspended metal particles are better than more suspended metal particles, sounds credible to me!
On the other hand, it's not like my oil analyses come back with 0 ppm for wear metals! (shrug)
www.filtermagindustrial.com
www.shopfiltermag.com
Oil sample is in the mail to the lab.